Method | Â | Clean | 20 dB | 15 dB | 10 dB | 5 dB | Average |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MFCC | Â | 76.38 | 59.44 | 44.24 | 22.34 | 5.85 | 32.97 |
CHN | Â | 76.52 | 61.40 | 52.71 | 38.06 | 24.30 | 44.12 |
| α=1.0 | 77.15 | 62.83 | 53.96 | 39.62 | 25.09 | 45.38 |
 | α=0.6 | 76.94 | 63.48 | 54.99 | 40.76 | 27.10 | 46.58 |
| α=1.0 | 77.50 | 63.62 | 54.45 | 39.79 | 25.91 | 45.94 |
 | α=0.6 | 76.07 | 63.11 | 55.22 | 40.35 | 26.94 | 46.41 |
| α=1.0 | 77.08 | 61.38 | 51.89 | 38.06 | 24.44 | 43.94 |
 | α=0.6 | 76.84 | 62.55 | 54.34 | 40.60 | 26.61 | 46.03 |
| α=1.0 | 76.91 | 62.38 | 53.15 | 38.43 | 23.81 | 44.44 |
 | α=0.6 | 76.59 | 63.15 | 54.50 | 40.14 | 26.14 | 45.98 |
| α=1.0 | 77.96 | 63.04 | 54.15 | 39.83 | 25.63 | 45.66 |
 | α=0.6 | 76.54 | 63.62 | 55.27 | 41.51 | 26.84 | 46.81 |
| α=1.0 | 77.31 | 63.27 | 54.24 | 39.65 | 25.75 | 45.73 |
 | α=0.6 | 76.33 | 62.62 | 55.29 | 40.81 | 26.82 | 46.39 |
| α=1.0 | 77.92 | 62.50 | 53.19 | 39.86 | 24.98 | 45.13 |
 | α=0.6 | 77.01 | 63.48 | 54.90 | 41.02 | 27.08 | 46.62 |
| α=1.0 | 77.10 | 62.55 | 52.80 | 38.18 | 24.91 | 44.61 |
 | α=0.6 | 77.24 | 63.13 | 54.52 | 40.88 | 26.91 | 46.36 |