Method | Â | Clean | 20 dB | 15 dB | 10 dB | 5 dB | Average |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MFCC | Â | 76.38 | 30.08 | 14.72 | 6.23 | 3.52 | 13.64 |
CHN | Â | 76.52 | 55.22 | 43.56 | 30.90 | 18.84 | 37.13 |
| α=1.0 | 77.15 | 56.48 | 46.81 | 33.05 | 19.40 | 38.94 |
 | α=0.6 | 76.94 | 59.28 | 49.81 | 36.80 | 22.74 | 42.16 |
| α=1.0 | 77.50 | 56.30 | 47.62 | 33.75 | 19.82 | 39.37 |
 | α=0.6 | 76.07 | 59.63 | 49.88 | 36.73 | 23.74 | 42.50 |
| α=1.0 | 77.08 | 55.92 | 44.94 | 32.09 | 19.36 | 38.08 |
 | α=0.6 | 76.84 | 58.68 | 48.44 | 36.22 | 23.11 | 41.61 |
| α=1.0 | 76.91 | 54.71 | 45.29 | 32.02 | 19.22 | 37.81 |
 | α=0.6 | 76.59 | 58.14 | 48.95 | 35.89 | 23.11 | 41.52 |
| α=1.0 | 77.96 | 56.88 | 47.46 | 33.82 | 20.94 | 39.78 |
 | α=0.6 | 76.54 | 59.75 | 49.79 | 36.89 | 23.72 | 42.54 |
| α=1.0 | 77.31 | 57.79 | 47.83 | 33.91 | 20.85 | 40.10 |
 | α=0.6 | 76.33 | 59.86 | 49.72 | 37.24 | 24.37 | 42.80 |
| α=1.0 | 77.92 | 57.18 | 46.36 | 33.70 | 20.64 | 39.47 |
 | α=0.6 | 77.01 | 59.98 | 49.11 | 36.26 | 23.53 | 42.22 |
| α=1.0 | 77.10 | 57.11 | 46.46 | 34.40 | 20.90 | 39.72 |
 | α=0.6 | 77.24 | 60.07 | 49.91 | 36.85 | 23.65 | 42.62 |