Skip to main content

Table 3 Comparison of the user effort invested in correcting the initial estimation of static onset detectors in terms of the R GT. The F-measure column shows the performance of the static detection method, whereas \(R_{\text {GT}}^{man}\) refers to the effort invested when considering a complete manual correction of the results. \(R_{\text {GT}}^{thres}\) and \(R_{\text {GT}}^{pctl}\) stand for the user effort in the threshold-based and percentile-based correction approaches, respectively

From: Interactive user correction of automatically detected onsets: approach and evaluation

ODF

OSF

F-measure

R GTman

R GTthres

R GTpctl

SFB

Threshold

0.5±0.2

0.41±0.05

0.34±0.01

0.43±0.02

 

Percentile

0.59±0.07

0.45±0.03

0.34±0.01

0.44±0.01

PS

Threshold

0.4±0.2

0.44±0.03

0.37±0.01

0.43±0.01

 

Percentile

0.55±0.08

0.44±0.02

0.37±0.01

0.43±0.01

SM

Threshold

0.4±0.2

0.45±0.03

0.38±0.01

0.43±0.01

 

Percentile

0.55±0.08

0.45±0.01

0.38±0.01

0.44±0.01

CDD

Threshold

0.19±0.10

0.54±0.04

0.51±0.01

0.57±0.01

 

Percentile

0.26±0.05

0.57±0.02

0.52±0.01

0.57±0.01

RCDD

Threshold

0.4±0.2

0.44±0.04

0.35±0.01

0.44±0.02

 

Percentile

0.57±0.08

0.45±0.02

0.36±0.01

0.44±0.01

PD

Threshold

0.14±0.11

0.54±0.04

0.52±0.01

0.59±0.01

 

Percentile

0.32±0.06

0.59±0.03

0.52±0.01

0.59±0.01

WPD

Threshold

0.4±0.2

0.45±0.03

0.38±0.01

0.43±0.01

 

Percentile

0.54±0.08

0.45±0.01

0.38±0.01

0.44±0.01

MKLD

Threshold

0.2±0.2

0.48±0.02

0.36±0.01

0.46±0.01

 

Percentile

0.56±0.08

0.46±0.02

0.36±0.01

0.46±0.01

SF

Threshold

0.30±0.19

0.48±0.02

0.44±0.01

0.46±0.01

 

Percentile

0.48±0.06

0.52±0.03

0.44±0.01

0.47±0.01

SuF

Threshold

0.4±0.2

0.42±0.07

0.26±0.01

0.40±0.03

 

Percentile

0.64±0.08

0.42±0.07

0.26±0.01

0.40±0.02

  1. Symbol denotes the cases in which the deviation is lower than the second significant decimal figure