Skip to main content

Table 3 Results for the development set

From: Replay attack detection with auditory filter-based relative phase features

Feature EER (%)
MFCC 13.78
CQCC 6.81
MGDCC 25.29
Original-RP 14.50
Mel-scale RP 9.57
Gammatone-scale RP 10.84
MFCC + CQCC 5.31
CQCC + MGDCC 12.08
MFCC + Mel-scale RP 6.05
MFCC + gammatone-scale RP 7.77
CQCC + Mel-scale RP 5.82
CQCC + gammatone-scale RP 5.33
CQCC (6–8 kHz) (result in [17]) 5.13
VESA-IFCC (result in [18]) 4.63
Voice source + instantaneous frequency + cepstral features + CQCC (result in [20]) 5.31
RFCC + LFCC (result in [19]) -